Musings
New Hampshire's license plates reflect the state's motto: "Live free or die." I have always felt this to be a somewhat extreme set of positions. After all, if you die, you're not going to live free, but if you can survive to fight another day, you might just get that chance.
Heroes have always worried me, especially since we use the term so loosely these days. It's laudatory for someone to charge into a hopeless fray attempting to turn the tide, hoping that others will follow suit. But it's frightening when that person is able to order others to do so in the name of some personal glory. If your fighter is beaten, throw in the towel and help him to recover, don't insist on his suffering greater harm because you want to be known as a "never say die" fight manager. If you're the tail gunner, you might not be happy if the pilot suddenly decides to go on a suicide mission.
I've had the unpleasant experience of working with executives who, in search of personal glory and compensation, have urged, required, and rewarded their people for unethical and sometimes illegal acts in order to "win the prize" and "achieve the win." Heaven save us from arrogant leaders.
True leaders (of corporations, institutions, communities, and families) have perspective. The succeed through good works, lessons learned, and charitable reactions. The antithesis is the parent who screams in incoherent rage at the other team, the officials, and the fates, sometimes culminating in physical attacks and, amazingly, some deaths. Insisting that your kid win at all costs (one father was convicted of assault for sharpening the metal fittings on his son's football gear so as to inflict injury on tacklers), or that your "team" win no matter what (I had to explain ethical conduct to a vice president who insisted his agents forge the name of insurance prospects on applications), or that everyone have your zeal for your personal triumphs (quite a few of you were told that if you didn't work long hours you weren't a "team player"), is the ultimate in pathological behavior.
There is also a difference between "hero" and "victim." The latter is someone caught up in a situation where he or she is hurt through others' actions (and sometimes their own). The former are people who go out of their way to proactively perform valiant acts. A golf putt, a large cash donation, and a performer going on despite illness do not, for me, qualify as heroic acts. Putting one's life at stake does. As much as we may mourn and want to defend victims, they are not heroes in that sense.
There are, I believe, heroic decisions. Eisenhower's decision to proceed with D-Day despite problematic weather and the fact that his own life was not at risk was heroic. Nearly everything Lincoln did to save the Union and abolish slavery was heroic. Gandhi, Mother Theresa, and Martin Luther King all strike me as heroic (and, of course, one could make the case their lives were on the line due to animosity and disease, though this was not an immediate threat).
Was John F. Kennedy heroic when he saved a life through valiant swimming and superb judgment after the PT 109 was sent to the bottom of the ocean? He apparently didn't think so. He told an admiring inquirer once that what he did was forced upon him since, after all, they had sunk his boat.
I think that heroes ought to be in short supply. And their actions should be singular, not dependent on others joining them or being ordered into the fray. We all have to decide when to gather our wherewithal to live free. I suspect we all would do our absolute best if they sunk our boat.
ORTIYKMWOYBNT-O Department
One day I was attempting to teach Danielle, my then-18-year-old daughter, how to drive a stick shift in my convertible. We drove to a Dunkin' Donuts where she gamely but inexpertly struggled to back the car into a space on a hill, the clutch screaming, the engine revving, every eye on us. She finally stalled the engine and, royally perturbed, went in to get us coffee. One onlooker remarked in stentorian tones, "Look at what he allows his trophy girlfriend to do to that lovely car! What a crime!"
Danielle was incensed and demanded I drive home. I did, feeling rather good about myself.